Phase 3: The Propaganda of Integration

Creating uniformity of thought, bringing outliers into the fold "by force if necessary."

L

RESHAPE MEDIA, EDUCATION, AND THE ARTS.

News, literature, education, the arts, (and today, social media) are brought into line with the new narrative. History is rewritten. Unofficial sources must be suppressed or prohibited until the public receives only the official interpretation of events.

page 125

The required "radical change of opinions and behavior as dictated by the new regime," which Mucchielli likens to mass religious conversion, will not be brought about by brutality and fear alone. Controlling education, the media, and the arts is just a start... "The one-dimensionality of the environment is an absolute must," Mucchielli says. "Everything must be coherent and carry the same values, the same symbols, the same myths."

L

THE NEW SCAPEGOAT

Introduction of the “enemy within.” This increases cohesion among the group members, and creates an emotional tension favorable to the injection of propaganda.

page 101

In the propaganda of integration, the scapegoat returns, but in a different form. Now the target is the sinister forces within...

Mucchielli points out the multiple advantages of the "enemy within" scapegoat:
• They divert anger, and serve as an outlet for the group's emotion, while channeling it away from the leaders...
• It intensifies the cohesion of the group by using the group reflex of survival in the face of an enemy or in the face of danger.

L

PARADE THE DEFEATED

Parading the defeated scapegoat proves their existence.

Even more than in Phase 1, the scapegoat cannot be created with rallies or lectures or even writings. The enemy within and their intent to destroy the group must be felt viscerally, with the "traitors" hunted down (perhaps reported on), unmasked, and paraded publicly in defeat before being silenced:

It is very important, therefore, that this figure of the 'Enemy' is not an abstraction or a simple story. It is very important to bring proof, to organize the spectacular demonstration of its existence. Hence the publicity given to certain 'documents,' to certain 'confessions,' to certain 'captures'; faces will be shown, treachery will be made palpable and perceptible...

Parading the defeated enemy in public or in media, with photos, films, walking of chained prisoners, etc. feeds the psychosis, demonstrates the "concrete" existence of the conspiracy and the danger, and displays the vulnerability and weakness of the opposition in the face of the omnipotent leader and his supporters.

page 70

L

THE PURGE

Civil servants and members of the military who cannot be counted on to comply with the new regime are purged and replaced with loyalists..

page 118

On 7 April, one week after the beginning of nationwide boycotts of Jewish businesses, the Reich Ministry of the Interior issued the "Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service" (also known as the Civil Service Law), purging all racial and political "enemies" of the regime— Jews, leftists, liberals, and people too independent in their thought— from the German civil service. To "restore a national professional civil service," it said, "civil servants who are not of Aryan descent are to be retired." Similarly, "Civil servants whose previous political activities afford no assurance that they will at all times give their fullest support to the national State, can be dismissed from the service."

L

THE POLICE STATE

Police terror and surveillance becomes the norm.

page 102

The "enemy within" scapegoat allows the development of police terror; a police state becomes necessary to "assure the security and peace of the group." The authorities must hunt down traitors for the continued survival of the group.On a national scale this requires the spilling of blood and/or the establishment of prison camps.

L

RESHAPE GROUPS AND CHURCHES

Churches and professional or political groups that promote loyalty to leaders who are outside the regime (or overseas) are controlled or eliminated.

page 127

This, Mucchielli says, emerges from research in psychology on the role of groups in creating a person's "personal identity and opinions." Unsettlingly, he says these experimental discoveries have made "new and powerful weapons possible," including:
- Destruction of the previous groups in society, including reducing the role of family cells; controlling or eliminating religious groups and Churches, putting all professional groups under state control.
- Intensification of public life, as provided by the state, including meetings, reunions, parades, festivals, fairs, solidarity days, etc.
- Use, inside groups, of peer pressure to conform, which also helps to identify opponents within the group and single them out for "special treatment."
- Reinforcement of conformist attitudes with rewards, gratification, publicity, and the sanction of nonconformist attitudes.

L

RESTRUCTURE THE LEGAL SYSTEM

Judges who don’t comply with the principles of the new regime (i.e. deliver unacceptable judgments) are removed. Tribunals may replace the courts. The rule of law is replaced with “the will of the people.”

page 119

In the judicial system, judges that were viewed as non-compliant with Nazi laws or principles (i.e. those who delivered unacceptable judgments) were removed. Jewish and socialist judges, lawyers, and other court officers were purged from their professions. The rule of law was dismantled -- judges were instructed to let "healthy folk sentiment" (gesundes Volksempflnden), rather than the letter of the law, guide them in their decisions...

[When he didn't get a verdict he wanted], Hitler's furious response was to dismantle the Supreme Court, replacing it with the People's Court (Volksgerichtshof), manned by judges chosen specifically for their Nazi beliefs, to try treason and other important "political cases." The People's Court would condemn tens of thousands of people as "Volk Vermin" and thousands more to death for "Volk Treason."

L

RESHAPE THE PERMANENT ENVIRONMENT

Media, public figures, advertising, slogans, even statues and billboards, must fit the new narrative. Definitions of words are changed and distorted to fit the new narrative. In Mucchielli’s psychological terms, “By changing the stimuli from the environment, we change the behavioral patterns. Changing the perceptual frame of reference forces thought to 'reorganize' itself.”

page 119

Part of achieving integration, [Mucchielli] says, is the "reshaping of the perceptive atmosphere" (i.e., the world we see) and completely altering the stimuli coming from the environment. Signs, banners, enemy within portraits, slogans, clothing, etc. all provide "suggestion" that makes old habits and reflexes null and void. "Disconcerted, no longer finding his usual reference points, the individual 'de-conditions' himself and, being able to adapt only in relation to these new reference points— the only ones that are there— reconditions himself in conformity."

IT MUST BE TOTALITARIAN

“LET US EMPHASIZE THE NEED FOR PROPAGANDA OF THIS KIND TO GO ALL THE WAY IN EACH OF ITS INITIATIVES. ONE OF THE MOST SERIOUS FACTORS OF FAILURE IS HALFMEASURES.

"EVERY TECHNIQUE MUST BE TOTALITARIAN, OR IT WILL BE INEFFECTIVE; IT IS THIS INTERNAL REQUIREMENT THAT MAKES BOTH THE INHUMANITY AND THE FUNDAMENTAL FRAGILITY OF THESE PROCESSES.”

Roger Mucchielli