Phase 2: The Propaganda of Agitation

Tipping the thirst for aggression into violence.

L

GET PAST THE BRAKES

People have “brakes” on harming their neighbors. To get past this one needs to bypass the rational mind and ignite the "primal" mind, the same "mind" that causes a pack of animals to stampede.

page 36

So how do you get someone to wander down the road of fantastical claims and wild assumptions? According to Mucchielli the first obstacle faced by the propagandist who wants to foment violence is that virtually all civilized soci-eties have common values, which generally include not doing physical harm to one's neighbors or countrymen. We all have built-in brakes against smashing someone else's businesses, burning their home, or picking up a weapon and attacking our neighbor. One of the most cherished fundamentals of Christianity, the Ten Commandments, prohibits both murder and bearing false witness.

The challenge to the propagandist is how to neutralize those brakes that allow societies to function in a civilized manner. Or, as Mucchielli puts it, "the barriers that reason and moral conscience put in the way." There is a way to do this, and it has been around for a long time.

L

THE WATCHWORD

A sign the phase has shifted is when the slogan changes from aspirations to a call to action, such as a shift from "Make America Great Again" to "Stop the Steal," or "Save America."

page 91

When the propaganda phase shifts from indoctrination to agitation, the slogan becomes a call to action, a call for the hammer to come down. As Mucchielli describes it, "the watchword is the striking formula of the short-term action to be undertaken, or of the immediate results to be obtained." The slogan calling the followers to the Capitol on January 6 was "Stop the Steal." The first slogan of Donald Trump's 2024 campaign was "Save America." These do not reflect aspirations. They are calls to action.

L

SPEAK TO THE PRIMITIVE MIND

The “mind” you are talking to “thinks” in simple terms. Hyper-simplify data and causes. There are only two sides, us and the others, good and evil. It is a battle of the forces of light vs the forces of darkness.

From Mucchillie: "In all propaganda, in order to be able to reach the most elementary levels of comprehension and to use a very deep archaic scheme in humans (day and night becoming symbols of life and death, light and darkness, truth and lie, good and evil), there is a hyper-simplification of data and causes, doctrines and intentions. 'He who is not with us is against us.' There are only two sides: us and the others. All the others are 'objectively complicit'. We are your life, the way, the truth, the light; they are therefore death, the impasse, the lie, the darkness."

page 92

L

IMMINENT DANGER AND COLLAPSE

"If we do not win, your country, your culture, your values, even your religion, will be destroyed."

In Phase 2, the Propaganda of Agitation, the hatred is moved from a thirst for violence to the physical attack. This is accomplished by painting and continuing to reinforce the "reality" around the group members that the forces of evil are gathering, that the battle between good and evil is coming, the ultimate settling of the future, whether it will be in hands of the good and the Godly or collapse into dark at the hands of the evil. It instills the fear of the complete destruction of one's culture, perhaps their religion, the fear that one's values, and all that one holds precious, will be strangled.

page 18

L

VIOLENCE WILL SAVE THE NATION

In every example those committing atrocities and killing believed that there was a “cancer” in the midst of the nation that would destroy the nation and had to be removed for the nation to survive.

These examples share another common denominator: in each case the violent mobs attacking their fellow citizens fervently and feverishly believed they were being patriots and saving their nation. They did not use the word "patriot" lightly. In the reality that had been woven around them, they were saving their nations from imminent destruction.

page 21

L

RECRUIT FROM THE PULPIT

Also in every example, churches were encouraged to “bless” the new leaders with the promise of influence under the new regime. Members believes they were eliminating enemies of God or people out to destroy their religion.

In May, 2022, right-wing Pastor Greg Locke, who has 1.8 million followers on Facebook, shouted from the pulpit that he did not want Democrats in his Church. He is not alone, though his language is more colorful than most. "If you're a Democrat," he said, "Get out, you demon. You get out, you baby-butchering election thief. You cannot be a Christian and vote Democrat in this nation. They are God-denying demons that hate this nation." As the murmurs of the congregation turn to cheers, Locke said "Everyone talks about the insurrection. Let me tell you something. You ain't seen the insurrection yet. You keep pushing our buttons, you low-down, sorry compromisers, you God-hating communists, you'll find out what an insurrection is." The audience broke into applause.

The Evangelical Christian coalition behind the Trump campaign did not just "come together." Like the Buddhist support of the military regime in Myanmar, it was orchestrated and well executed, and continues to be built and agitated, by an adept and well-trained propagandist. .

page 78

L

PUT THE MILITIAS IN PLACE

Recruit, arm, and train. Ensure their loyalty to the new leader is 100%. They may supplement local law enforcement or military. But they are not bound by legal constraints and can act solely on the orders of the leader.

Germany: This network of independent militias proliferated across Germany and in other parts of Europe. The Freikorps were initially composed of veterans of the war, some of whom had returned mentally or physically damaged and were not able to reintegrate into civilian society. Humiliated by their defeat in the war, the camaraderie and heroic spirit of brothers in battle provided by the pseudo-military structure of the militia at home gave them a place to land. They were still at war, though now, with little to no regulation, they were even more unbridled... In 1923 the members of the Bavarian Freikorps group were used to form the Sturmabteilung, or SA, the militia attached to the newly formed National Socialist Party, the Nazi party. The SA were assigned to provide military protection for the party while also advancing Nazi ideology.

page 110

page 189

Indonesia: Youth were organized into militia, including the Students' Action Front (KAMI), the Indonesian Youth and Students' Action Front (KAPPI), and the Indonesian University Alumni Action Front (KASI). Anyone aligned or even sympathetic to the PKI was painted as an enemy intent on destroying the nation-even illiterate peasants in remote villages were accused of participating in the plot. The killings began in October 1965, in Jakarta, and spread to Central and Eastern Java, Bali, and other parts of Indonesia...

page 193

Rwanda: [Propaganda radio station] RTLM recruited the militia that would do the bidding of the extremist Hutus. It created the Rwandan version of the Nazi brown shirts. Between January 1993 and March 1994, millionaire Felicien Kabuga, one of the funders of both Kangura and RTLM, simultaneously imported 500,000 machetes in preparation for what was to come127. On April 6, 1994, a plane carrying Rwandan president Juvenal Habyarimana and Burundian president Cyprien Ntaryamira was shot out of the sky with surface-to-air missiles as it prepared to land in the Rwandan capital of Kigali. They were returning from peace negotiations with the Tutsi. A half hour after the crash, the militia members set up checkpoints in the cities and the killing began.

L

STAGE THE CATASTROPHIC EVENT

Staged and blamed on the (unprepared and unarmed) opposition or scapegoat, it unleashes the violence against them. The chaos is "resolved" by overthrow (as in Myanmar) or in handing of dictatorial powers to the new regime (as in Germany and Indonesia).

Once they are fully enmeshed in the "new reality," all that is needed then is to unleash them and direct them where to go. Historically, this has been accompanied by a "catastrophic event" (a fire, an attack, etc.) that has been blamed on the opposition, starting the mass violence. When the violence is sufficient to collapse the nation, the new regime deposes the government and steps in to "restore order."

page 19

"While the scapegoat is the mechanism used to agitate the violence, once unleashed, the violence is rarely limited to them."